North and South, Elizabeth Gaskell

North and SouthNorth and South by Elizabeth Gaskell

First Published: 1854-5
Pages: 544 including afterword (Paperback)
Form: Novel

Rating: 3/5 = I liked it3/5 = I liked it3/5 = I liked it3/5 = I liked it3/5 = I liked it

Elizabeth Gaskell’s compassionate, richly dramatic novel features one of the most original and fully-rounded female characters in Victorian fiction, Margaret Hale. It shows how, forced to move from the country to an industrial northern town, she develops a passionate sense of social justice, and a turbulent relationship with mill-owner John Thornton.

North and South depicts a young woman discovering herself, in a nuanced portrayal of what divides people, and what brings them together.

So I guess the best way to succinctly sum up my feelings on this book is to repeat what I told my mum when she asked how I was enjoying it: ‘the TV adaptation is better than the book, and the story is better than the writing’.

North and South is a story I’ve been in love with since I watched the BBC adaptation with Richard Armitage in 2004. It’s basically Pride and Prejudice in an industry Victorian city, with class issues and commentary mainly replacing the originals gender issues. Mr Darcy is mill owner and self-made-man, Mr. Thornton, while Elizabeth Bennet is the socially conscious and initially insufferably snobby, Margret Hale. Instead of Pemberly and the Bennet sister’s there’s a backdrop of industrial revolution, class tension, and trade union strikes and a supporting cast ranging from servents and mill hands to lawyers and Oxford academics.

Gaskell, though, is no Austen and I found her writing very hard to get into at first. Less wit and charm and more turgid preaching and moralising. Neither of which I am particularly patient with. It improved towards the middle, where the older characters start suddenly dropping like flies, but the first half was a real slog. Gaskell does that Victorian omniscient narrator thing where, instead of  enhancing the understanding of the side characters by popping into their thoughts, it ends up dully explaining everything and robbing the book of any tension. All tell and no show, especially at the beginning when we’re meant to be forming our first impressions of the characters. No disagreement between Margaret and Mr. Thornton (or anybody else for that matter) is allowed without instantly flitting into Thornton’s thoughts to let us know that it’s just a misunderstanding, that he didn’t explain himself properly, and that he finds Margaret beautiful. Kinda robs the romantic tension somewhat. Which is probably why I prefer the TV version so hard, Richard Armitage can convey Thornton’s feeling more effectively in a single look than Gaskell can in a whole chapter.

And then there’s also the preachiness. The only character more insufferable for it than Margaret (who spends a good quarter of the book angsting over telling a lie – to save somebody’s life but it was a lie) is Bessy, the terminally ill mill worker who spends every waking moment talking about how glorious heaven will be when she gets there. It’s genuinely cringe inducing and after about two pages I was wishing she would just pass away and put me out of my misery.

But three stars because I do like the story itself, the social commentary is interesting (if a little moralising in places), and once I got into the book (about the halfway point) the writing seemed to improve so by the end I was enjoying the novel more than I was frustrated with it. I also really like the side characters of Higgins, the trade unionist and Mrs. Thornton, Mr. Thornton’s imposing mother who doesn’t put up with any of Margaret’s fancy southern shit. The romance, I thought, was unconvincing but, I think, even Gaskell found that the secondary point after exploring the social tensions between the working class and the ‘masters’, the industrial north and the rural south. So after a tricky and deeply frustrating start, I did end up enjoying (if not always agreeing with) this book.

Will probably be a while before I decide to read another Gaskell though, and if I do it’ll probably be a library jobby. The ideas and plot may be good, but I’m not sure her prose has aged particularly well.

Definitely rate the TV version better.



Filed under Novels, Reviews

3 responses to “North and South, Elizabeth Gaskell

  1. classicsjournal

    I think it’s harder to start off with North & South for Gaskell. Partly because it was originally written in installments. I much preferred her Wives and Daughters. There are the books she wrote to bring attention to social issues like North & South, Mary Barton, and Ruth. And those she wrote for pleasure, nice cosy stories like, Cranford and Wives and Daughters. I haven’t read Sylvia’s Lovers so I can’t say where it falls.

  2. Have heard a lot of people rate Wives and Daughters better actually. I did manage to enjoy North and South in the end so I’m willing to give Gaskell another try and that’s definitely top of the list for next time. It just might take a while to get round to it.

  3. Love this novel. It’s my favorite all-time romance. Yes, romance! lol! I thoroughly enjoy Gaskell’s subtleties in character development (you have to realize everything that Margaret is going through and doing to ‘get’ her) AND the narrative and descriptive prose. I’m convinced that, far from being window dressing, the love story is the backbone of the whole novel, displaying and emphasizing every social point she want to make to the reader. To me, Gaskell is challenging her Victorian readers to look beyond all the artificial divides between people and to value who people are as individuals. Wives and Daughters is a walk in the park comparatively. And a very nice, leisurely walk in the park, I must add. Loved that book as well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s